Car news · · 27UsedCar

US Wholesale Used Car Prices Edge Up in Early October on Tight Supply

Cox data: the Manheim index rose 0.7% to 207.4 in the first half of October, and an analyst says tight supply, not stronger demand, is the main reason.

US Wholesale Used Car Prices Edge Up in Early October on Tight Supply

Cox Automotive published the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index for the first half of October on October 19. The index tracks what US used cars sell for at wholesale auctions, which means the prices dealers pay each other, not the prices consumers see on a lot. Wholesale is the dealer's purchase cost, so it may be where the direction of retail prices shows up first.

First half of October: the index reaches 207.4

According to Cox Automotive, the index, adjusted for seasonality, mileage and vehicle mix, rose to 207.4. That is up 0.7% from September and up 2.2% from a year earlier. The index is set at 100 for January 1997, so 207.4 means wholesale prices are a little more than double that starting point.

Unadjusted prices tell a different story. In the first half of October they were down about 2% from September and up 0.5% year over year. In a typical October, unadjusted prices fall about 1.5% over the full month, because autumn is a seasonally softer period for wholesale values. The two sets of numbers do not contradict each other: the adjusted index strips out the seasonal pattern and so shows a gain, while raw prices are still sliding the way they normally do at this time of year.

For three-year-old vehicles, Manheim's reference valuation (the MMR) has fallen 1.2% since the start of October. That is slightly less than the drop in the same period last year, and in line with the long-term average.

A weak comparison base lifts the annual gain

Jonathan Gregory, a senior director at Cox Automotive, pointed out that much of the 2.2% year-over-year gain comes from an easy comparison. Wholesale prices were unusually weak in October last year, so almost any result looks good against them.

Demand has not clearly strengthened either. Gregory said dealer demand is roughly flat. The auction sales conversion rate averaged 54.3%, which is 0.3 points above a year ago and 0.3 points below September. He noted that two factors flagged in September, higher interest rates and weaker consumer sentiment, have not gone away.

He also cautioned that some of October's weakness may already have been pulled forward into September's decline, so the full month is needed to see whether this steadier start holds. Cox plans to publish the full-month October figures on November 6.

Tighter supply is holding prices up

Gregory's explanation is that supply, not demand, has slowed the fall in prices. Days' supply in the wholesale market is the number of days the current stock would last at the current sales pace. At the end of September it stood at 28.7 days, 2.5 days more than a year earlier. By October 15 it had dropped to 28.2 days, only about one day above last year. As the gap with last year narrows and sellers hold less stock, they may be less willing to cut prices.

In his reading, prices firmed because inventory is leaner, not because buyers are bidding harder. That is why he does not yet describe this as a buyer-led recovery.

The months before: a spring peak and a late-summer slide

Put in the context of the whole year, 207.4 is well below where the market stood in spring. Auto Remarketing reported that the index reached 215.3 in March, up 6.2% year over year, and quoted Cox chief economist Jeremy Robb as saying that used-vehicle demand was healthy and inventory relatively tight. In mid-June the index was 213.9, up 2.6% year over year.

The turn came in mid-September. The index fell to 206.2, down 0.4% year over year, and Gregory said that was the first negative year-over-year reading of 2026. The full month of September came in at 205.9, down 1.1% from August and 0.6% from a year earlier. Unadjusted prices dropped 1.3% from August, against an average September decline of about 0.3%. Cox pointed to higher fuel costs (diesel prices hit record highs), rising interest rates, the conflict in the Middle East and broader economic pressure. It also noted that this was the first September in decades without an Atlantic hurricane, and said the missing post-storm demand may have made the decline steeper. The Federal Reserve also raised rates in September for the first time in more than three years.

On October 7, Cox cut its full-year forecast. It now expects the index to end 2026 up only about 0.2% year over year, compared with the 2% rise it forecast in July. So the early-October rise is best read as a partial repair after a sharp September drop. The numbers show it: 207.4 is only 1.5 points above September's 205.9, and still about 7.9 points below March's 215.3.

Cox is cautious about what comes next. It names rising interest rates, falling consumer confidence and the Middle East conflict as near-term pressures. On the supportive side, it lists the aging US vehicle fleet, recovering fleet demand and growth in financial assets. In Robb's words, Cox is entering the fourth quarter "with our antennas up", meaning on alert. Cox also forecasts US wholesale volume of about 11.8 million vehicles in 2026, up less than 1% from 2025.

Segments: compact cars and EVs lead

By segment, compact cars posted the biggest annual gain, at 5.6%. Midsize cars have turned positive, luxury is slightly below last year, and pickups remain soft. Cox ties the strength in compact cars and EVs to persistently high fuel prices.

The EV index is up 6.8% year over year but down 0.7% from September. The non-EV index is up 1.3% year over year and up 0.7% month over month. The EV lead is narrowing: in mid-June its annual gain was 13.7%, and today it is less than half that. Cox notes that EVs have outperformed all year, but momentum is fading as more off-lease EVs reach the market. Cox's Q3 report adds background: EVs made up about 10% of off-lease supply in the first half of the year, are expected to reach about 16% in the second half, and may approach 19% by summer 2027. The same report shows that EV sales at Manheim auctions in the third quarter were up 45% from a year earlier and reached a record 4.9% of all transactions. Prices are rising more slowly while volumes grow, so EVs may be becoming an ordinary part of the wholesale market. The report also says diesel vehicles were just over 3% of wholesale inventory but their days' supply rose to 39, 27% higher than a year ago; demand and values for large pickups and SUVs weakened; and older, cheaper vehicles depreciated less.

Retail: high average prices, fewer cheap cars

Wholesale prices take time to reach retail, so it helps to look at the latest retail data. In a report published on October 16, Cox Automotive said the average US used-vehicle listing price in September was $27,235, the highest monthly average since December 2022. That is essentially flat from August and up nearly 6% from a year ago. Total inventory was 2.21 million vehicles, up 3.3% year over year, and days' supply was 49, compared with 44 in August.

On sales, the September retail used-vehicle sales pace was 2% faster than a year earlier but 6.3% slower than August, with estimated retail volume of 1.35 million. Ford, Chevrolet, Toyota, Honda and Nissan were the top-selling used brands, together accounting for more than 49% of retail used sales.

The price bands differ sharply. Cars under $15,000 had only 34 days' supply, 15 days below the industry average. Inventory in that band is down 16.2% year over year, and its share of total inventory has fallen from 19.4% a year ago to 15.7%. Cox also expects off-lease wholesale volume to rise 23% in 2026, with monthly off-lease supply growing from about 190,000 units in the first half to about 220,000 in the second, which may add a batch of younger vehicles to the used market. In addition, Cox lists the timing of Chinese EV imports as one of the things to watch in 2027.

What this means for buyers

  • Do not apply the US index directly to other markets. It is a dollar price from US wholesale auctions and reflects the US vehicle mix, US interest rates and US fuel prices. Used-car prices in Algeria, the UK, France, Russia and the Middle East depend more on local supply and demand, duties, taxes and exchange rates.
  • Use it as a cross-check, not a guide. Recent readings of the adjusted US index, for half a month or a full month, have mostly moved 0.6% to 1.4% up or down. Changes in Chinese domestic car prices, exchange rates and sea freight may matter more to your landed cost. When you time a purchase, look at those first and treat the US index as one reference among several.
  • When fuel prices are high, small fuel-efficient cars and EVs sell more easily. The US data show this. If fuel is also expensive in your market, similar cars may see stronger demand, but check local conditions.
  • Used EV prices are sensitive to supply. The US case shows that more off-lease cars can slow price gains. When you compare quotes for Chinese used EVs, match the model year, battery capacity and range version, and confirm the charging port (Chinese domestic models use GB/T, while Europe commonly uses CCS2), the infotainment language and the registration paperwork.
  • Used cars under $15,000 turn over fastest in the US, and their share of inventory is shrinking, so cheap supply there is not plentiful. A US buyer thinking of importing a vehicle from China should first check federal safety and emissions rules and whether the specific vehicle complies; that is outside the scope of this article.
  • Cox will publish full-month October data on November 6. If the rise continues, it may mean the tight-supply pattern is still in place; if prices fall back, the early-October gain may have been only a repair. Either way it is just one cross-check on the market, and it does not replace checking each vehicle's condition, specification and total landed cost.

Original article

Editorial review: 27UsedCar ·

A clearer view of the market.

Used cars, shipping updates and buying guides, in your language.

By subscribing, you agree to receive market updates. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

WhatsApp